- Agency
- New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, Income Tax Audit
- Two tests
- Domicile in New York, or statutory residency under Tax Law section 605(b)
- Statutory residency
- A permanent place of abode kept for substantially all of the year, plus more than 183 days in New York
- Day count
- Any part of a day in New York counts, except presence solely in transit or while confined for medical treatment
- Protest
- Generally 90 days from the notice of deficiency, to conciliation (Form CMS-1-MN) or the Division of Tax Appeals (Form TA-100)
New York taxes its residents on all of their income and nonresidents only on income from New York sources, so the question of residency can be worth a great deal. A residency audit examines whether someone who filed as a nonresident or part-year resident was in fact a resident. The Tax Department can reach that conclusion in two independent ways: by finding that the person’s domicile remained in New York, or by finding that the person met the statutory residency test, and either finding is sufficient.
Domicile
Domicile is the place a person intends to be a permanent home and to return to when away. A person has only one, and it continues until a new one is established. The burden of proving a change of domicile falls on whoever asserts the change, and the evidence has to be clear and convincing. For someone who left New York that burden is the taxpayer’s, and for a longtime resident of another state it is the Department’s.
The Department’s Nonresident Audit Guidelines direct auditors to compare a person’s ties to New York with the ties to the claimed new home under five primary factors:
- Home. The size, value and use of each residence, and what was kept or sold.
- Active business involvement. Where the person works or continues to run a business.
- Time. Where the person actually spends the year.
- Items near and dear. The location of possessions of sentimental or personal value.
- Family connections. Where a spouse and minor children live and attend school.
The guidelines tell auditors that the analysis in nearly all cases is decided on these primary factors, and that other factors such as voter registration, a driver’s license and the address on bank statements need not be explored unless the primary factors point toward New York or are evenly balanced. People planning a move often attend to the formal items and overlook the five that carry the weight.
Statutory residency
A person who is domiciled elsewhere is still a New York resident for the year if two things are true: the person maintained a permanent place of abode in New York for substantially all of the year, and spent more than 183 days of the year in the state. The Department’s audit policy since tax year 2022 treats “substantially all of the year” as a period exceeding ten months; before that the threshold was eleven. Any part of a day spent in New York counts as a day, with narrow exceptions. Presence solely to board a plane, ship, train or bus for a destination outside the state is disregarded, as is travel that began outside New York and continues through it to a point outside. The guidelines give the example of a Connecticut resident who goes to JFK to catch a flight to Europe. Days of confinement in a medical institution for treatment are also left out of the count.
Owning or renting a dwelling in New York does not settle the abode question either. The Court of Appeals held in Matter of Gaied that a taxpayer must have a residential interest in the dwelling, so there has to be some basis to conclude that it was used as the taxpayer’s residence.
This is the test that catches commuters. Someone who lives in Greenwich or Stamford, works in Manhattan and keeps an apartment in the city for late nights has the abode, and the day count then depends on working days, weekends in the city and every other occasion for crossing the state line. New York City applies the same approach for its own resident income tax, so an apartment in the city raises both questions together.
The guidelines place the practical burden on the taxpayer here. A person who maintains a New York abode and claims nonresident status must be able to substantiate, with adequate records, that no more than 183 days were spent in the state.
Rules for people domiciled in New York
Two statutory exceptions allow a New York domiciliary to be taxed as a nonresident. The first applies to a person who maintains no permanent place of abode in New York, maintains one elsewhere for the entire year, and spends no more than 30 days of the year in New York. The second, known as the 548-day rule, applies to people who are in a foreign country for most of a 548-day period and meet its other conditions. Both are narrow, and auditors test each condition.
How the audit proceeds
The audit usually opens with a letter and a request for information covering one or more of the last three years. For a day-count case the Department expects contemporaneous evidence of location, and the guidelines mention a diary, appointment log or calendar as the kind of record that supports the analysis. Auditors corroborate it with records such as credit card receipts, telephone bills and expense reports, which is why a day count prepared from memory rarely survives.
When the review is finished the Department issues a Statement of Proposed Audit Changes, and the taxpayer can respond with additional information. If the disagreement remains, a Notice of Deficiency follows. From its date there are generally 90 days to request a conciliation conference with the Bureau of Conciliation and Mediation Services on Form CMS-1-MN or to petition the Division of Tax Appeals on Form TA-100. The Department warns that this period is fixed by statute and is not extended by further correspondence with the auditor. A representative acts under a New York power of attorney, Form POA-1.
Preparing the case
Residency cases are decided on documents assembled into a day-by-day account. A statutory residency audit calls for a calendar for the full year, with each day assigned to a location and supported by something other than recollection. In a domicile audit the evidence is organized under each of the five primary factors and shows, with dates, how the balance shifted to the new home. The work is closer to a reconstruction than to a tax computation, and it is most persuasive when the gaps are identified and explained before the auditor finds them.
One point is often missed by people who divide their lives between Connecticut and New York. Being treated as a resident by both states in the same year is possible, and the credit each state gives for tax paid to the other does not always cover investment income. The exposure is therefore not limited to wages earned in New York.
Sources
- New York Department of Taxation and Finance, Nonresident Audit Guidelines (December 2021)
- New York Department of Taxation and Finance: Power of attorney (Form POA-1)
- New York Tax Law § 605, resident and nonresident defined
- Instructions for Form IT-203, Nonresident and Part-Year Resident Income Tax Return
- New York Publication 130-F, The New York State Tax Audit
- New York Publication 131, Your Rights and Obligations Under the Tax Law
This article describes the rules as of November 19, 2026. It is general information, not advice on a particular matter. Deadlines are set by the notice itself, so read yours.
If this notice or situation is yours: keep the document and its envelope, note the date on it, and contact us before the response date passes.